On Wednesday, Andrew Ross Sorkin asked Elon Musk about his politics at The New York Times’ DealBook Summit. Musk said:
I mean, I’m not MAGA. I’m not sure what MAGA means, but I, I don’t think I’m, like, if, if that means sort of blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican Party, then I certainly don’t have that.
He added that he felt “pretty foolish” about the money he spent on the midterms, and that he did not think he held “any kind of extreme political views.” He asked Sorkin to name one.
I laughed out loud when I read it. I am still laughing a little. But I want to be fair to him, because on the narrow question I think he is right. Musk is not MAGA, if MAGA means a set of convictions someone holds whether or not they are winning. My claim is that he is not an ideological Republican because he is not an ideological anything. He goes where the power is. The record of where he went does not change because the power moved.
The Record
On October 5, 2024, Musk joined Donald Trump on stage in Butler, Pennsylvania, at the site of the July assassination attempt. It was his first Trump rally. He wore a black cap with “Make America Great Again” on the front, jumped behind Trump at the podium, and told the crowd, according to the Associated Press: “As you can see I am not just MAGA. I am Dark MAGA.” He said that if Trump lost, “this will be the last election.” Three weeks later, at Madison Square Garden, he went further: “I’m not just MAGA. I am dark, gothic MAGA.”
On January 20, 2025, hours after the inauguration, he spoke at Trump’s victory rally in Washington:
This was no ordinary victory. This was a fork in the road of human civilization. … It is thanks to you that the future of civilization is assured.
He then ran the Department of Government Efficiency for about four months. He sat in at least one Cabinet meeting wearing a cap that read “Trump Was Right About Everything.”
He was not sure, on Wednesday, what MAGA means. In Butler, he was sure enough to put a darker version of it on his head.
Texas
The 2026 midterm is not ancient history. The New York Times counted about $474 million in Musk contributions from January 2025 through mid-October 2026, more than any donor who was not a candidate has given in a single cycle. About $212 million of it supported Ken Paxton, the Texas attorney general, in his Senate race against James Talarico. The AP reported that in the weeks before the vote Musk “shot off a slew of posts on X” against Talarico, almost entirely about his past positions on transgender rights. That was Paxton’s central attack too.
I have written about what that money bought in What Half a Billion Bought. The short version is that Talarico won by about twelve points, and the “Vote red today!” post Musk put up on Election Day was gone by the next afternoon. This is not the first time he has tried to take something back. In June 2025, during his public feud with Trump, he posted that Trump was in the Epstein files, deleted the posts within two days, and later said he had gone “too far.”
He can delete a post. He cannot delete the footage from Butler, the transcript from Washington, or the Federal Election Commission filings. People screenshot things. Reporters archive things. We know what he did, because he did it in public, on purpose, at volume. We are not as forgetful as this plan needs us to be.
Moderate
On Wednesday Musk also said he does not hold “any kind of extreme political views.” The test of that is not what he says about himself. It is what he did with the one government job he has held.
In February 2025, a month into running DOGE, he called the U.S. Agency for International Development “a criminal organization” and said on X that he had spent the weekend “feeding USAID into the wood chipper.” On February 20 he walked on stage at CPAC holding a chainsaw that Argentina’s president, Javier Milei, had handed him. “This is the chainsaw for bureaucracy,” he said. Two days later, federal employees got an email titled “What did you do last week?” Musk posted that failing to answer would be taken as a resignation. Several departments, including Defense and State, told their staff not to respond.
That email is the clearest look we got at how he leads. It went to the whole civilian workforce at once, from no one who knew any of them, and asked for five bullet points of accomplishments. The White House said more than a million people answered. Nobody explained who would read a million lists of bullets, or how a reader with no knowledge of a meteorologist’s or a claims examiner’s work would judge whether the week had been well spent. Within days, the Office of Personnel Management was telling agencies that leaders could exempt their staff at their own discretion.
The Government Accountability Office later counted what the year produced. Across the 22 largest federal agencies, nearly 378,000 employees left during 2025, and the workforce fell by about 256,000, more than 11 percent. The Department of Education lost more than 45 percent. Not all of that is his doing. He left DOGE after about four months, and the cuts ran on presidential orders. But he was the public face of them, and he chose the chainsaw as the image.
A person can believe the federal government is too large and still be a moderate. A person who talks about an agency as something for a wood chipper, and waves a chainsaw on stage for applause while the people who work there wait to learn whether they still have jobs, is not describing a moderate position. He is mocking them, and it was the movement’s mood.
Voters noticed. Democrats ran on it this fall. “Elon Musk waved a chain saw on stage and laughed while he fired public servants,” Rep. James Walkinshaw of Virginia wrote before the election. In Texas, the AP Voter Poll found that slightly more than half of voters viewed Musk unfavorably. The country was shown his management style for four months, and in November it voted against the party that hired him.
Where the Power Is
So why do I agree with him? Because the pattern makes more sense as a man following power than as a man following a movement.
In May 2025 he told Bloomberg he had “done enough” political spending. That summer he broke with Trump over the spending bill and floated a third party. By the end of the year they had reconciled. In 2026 he gave more than he had given in 2024. I made the longer version of this argument in He Can’t Have It Both Ways: the alignment is opportunistic, not ideological.
Wednesday fits the pattern. Musk did not appear at DealBook in person. He spoke by video from China, where, according to CNBC and The Independent, he was traveling with President Trump on his Asia trip. The party lost Congress, so he stepped back from the party’s brand. The president still holds the executive branch, so he stayed on the trip. He also told Sorkin that divided government is preferable to one party controlling Washington. Democrats take the House and Senate in January.
DOGE’s own theorist gives a way to measure the turn. In March 2025, Curtis Yarvin, the blogger whom two DOGE advisers credited with “the most crisp articulation” of what the effort was for, wrote that “cost reduction is not the proper metric for the performance of DOGE.” The real measure, he said, was “its ability to take power from the libs, then keep it.” I have written about that standard in The Theory That Cannot Fail. Judged by Yarvin’s metric, DOGE was meant to take power from the establishment. Two Novembers later, the man who ran it is telling the New York Times audience that both parties have their issues and that he would welcome divided government. The project was to break the establishment. Now that it has failed, he is asking to be let back in. It is the heel who spent the match hitting the babyface with a chair, lost anyway, and now walks to the ring with his hand out. Wrestling crowds know that handshake. It comes before the second chair shot.
Look at his definition, too. He says MAGA means “blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican Party.” That was never what MAGA meant. Plenty of Republicans who held to the party’s old policies on trade, deficits, and alliances were driven out of it. MAGA has been loyalty to one man. By that definition, the man calling in from the president’s trip has a better claim to it than most.
That is my reading, not something he has said. He may believe every word. But a moderate who discovers his moderation two weeks after his side loses, and not one week before, should expect to be asked about the timing.
The Next Move
This is the part that worries me more than Musk does.
Musk is not the only one. Earlier this month, Palantir’s CEO, Alex Karp, told Politico: “I’ve been a Democrat my whole life. I grew up in a far-left environment.” He said he would be willing to support a Democrat for president in 2028. The AP notes that Karp donated to Trump’s White House ballroom project and has described his own company as “anti-woke.”
The pitch from here is predictable. We were never really with them. We are moderates. We have money and we would like to help. Some Democrats will be tempted, because money is useful and a reformed billionaire makes a good story.
Democrats should say no. Not because people cannot change their minds. They can, and I would welcome a real change. But the evidence for a real change is behavior over time, not a statement made the week the investigations were announced. And Democrats in Texas just showed what the alternative looks like. Talarico and Gina Hinojosa, who beat Greg Abbott for governor, ran on billionaires versus everyday Texans and named Musk directly. “Paxton is funded by one dude,” Talarico told his last rally. “He wants his very own personal United States senator.” Voters agreed.
The Republican Party took the money, the rallies, and the man in the hat, and in exchange it let one donor buy a Senate nominee’s campaign. It is paying for that now. The lesson for Democrats is not that they should get their own billionaire. It is that they should not want one. A party that wins by running against bought politicians cannot turn around in January and start accepting the same offers.
Musk said on Wednesday that he is not sure what MAGA means. He knew in Butler. He was wearing it.
Sources
The DealBook interview:
- ‘I’m not MAGA,’ Elon Musk says after Republicans’ midterm thrashing (Associated Press via PBS News, Nov. 19, 2026)
- Elon Musk went from ‘dark MAGA’ to ’not MAGA’ after spending $445 million on a Republican midterm defeat (Fortune, Nov. 19, 2026)
- DealBook Summit 2026: Live updates (CNBC, Nov. 18, 2026)
- Elon Musk’s deMAGAfication (The Independent via Yahoo News, Nov. 2026)
The record:
- Elon Musk makes appearance at Trump rally in Butler, Pa. (Associated Press via WHYY, Oct. 2024)
- From bromance to breakup: How Elon Musk and Donald Trump blew up (NPR, June 5, 2025)
DOGE:
- Who is part of Elon Musk’s DOGE, and what are they doing? (NPR, Feb. 7, 2025)
- Musk waves a chainsaw and charms conservatives at CPAC (Associated Press, Feb. 20, 2025)
- Elon Musk says federal employees must either document their work, or lose their jobs (NPR, Feb. 22, 2025)
- Federal agencies still can’t agree on ‘What did you do last week?’ email (NPR, Feb. 24, 2025)
- ‘More than 1 million’ federal workers have responded to Doge’s ‘what did you do last week’ email, White House claims (The Guardian, Feb. 25, 2025)
- Federal Agency Workforce Changes: Update for July 2025 to January 2026 (GAO-26-108583, June 17, 2026)
Texas and the money:
- Elon Musk gambled $445 million to boost Republicans in the midterms. It came up short (Associated Press via PBS News, Nov. 5, 2026)
- Elon Musk tests what nearly half a billion dollars can buy in the midterms (New York Times via the Philadelphia Inquirer, Nov. 2, 2026)
Yarvin on DOGE:
- Barbarians and mandarins (Curtis Yarvin, Gray Mirror, Mar. 2025)
- Curtis Yarvin helped inspire DOGE. Now he scorns it. (Washington Post, May 8, 2025)
Related:

