On November 10, Dave Meltzer posted about Jim Cornette: “Many years ago he decided the Young Bucks & Kenny Omega (and they weren’t the only ones) would never make it in wrestling. Them making it in Japan led to Japan no longer counting.” Meltzer has published the Wrestling Observer Newsletter since the early 1980s. His star ratings are the closest thing this business has to a critic’s grade.
I replied:
I think the point your missing is that while it was over for one portion of the audience, it also pushed another away. Not saying Cornette’s ideas are any better but some of us do prefer more serious wrestling and AEW sometimes flies in the face of that. A legit point.
A little later I tried to reply to another comment in the thread and couldn’t. I spent a few minutes trying to work out why. He had blocked me. I was honestly shocked. I never thought Dave Meltzer would do that. I have since learned I am in good company. Dutch Mantell, a territory-era wrestler and booker, says Meltzer blocked him too. The same week, his replies were full of long arguments with anonymous accounts.
My claim is narrow. I do not care that Meltzer loves AEW. I am glad for him. My complaint is that he has stopped answering the argument against it. People with specific complaints get sorted into “haters,” and the person doing the sorting is the most trusted reporter in the business. That would matter less if the question could not be settled. It can. Wrestling used to settle it every week, at the box office.
Name-Calling
In November, Meltzer went back and forth on X with Cornette and Brian Last, Cornette’s podcast co-host. When someone called his posts a meltdown, he answered: “A guy obsessed with me weekly and I respond one night and it’s a ’twitter meltdown.’ By that standard you’d have to call yourself a 52 week a year meltdown.” Last’s summary of a later exchange was four words long: “Dave is name calling again.”
Here is one. I am not going to link every post. The rest are on his profile, and anyone can scroll through it and decide whether Last’s four words are fair.
I am not going to pretend Cornette and Last are neutral. Cornette’s channel posts videos about Meltzer regularly, and Last is promoting a compilation called the Decline of Dave Meltzer Omnibus. Their side throws insults too. But they are commentators. Nobody reads Brian Last to find out what happened backstage. Meltzer is a reporter, and a reporter’s adjectives get read as findings.
Nobody Is Listening
This is harder to write because I learned from him. I was a subscriber. I read the newsletter. His long posts are usually factual in the narrow sense: they list buy rates, gates, and ratings that very few people ever see. I have learned things from them.
But numbers do not settle a question of taste. We can argue about modern wrestling all day. Some people love it. Others do not. Splitting that argument into haters on one side and the people with data on the other is a trick, and it is the kind of trick I learned to spot partly by reading him. The data tells you how many people watched. It does not tell you that the people who stopped watching were wrong to stop. Nobody on his side of the thread is listening to why they stopped.
The Phone Calls
Meltzer talks with Tony Khan about the show, and he does not hide it. There is a clip of Khan calling him in the middle of a live show. During AEW’s Battle of the Belts VII broadcast in July 2023, the show missed the finish of the Toni Storm and Taya Valkyrie match. Meltzer said on his radio show that he messaged Khan while it was still on the air: “You’ve got to tell the people who won that match, because we don’t know.” The finish aired at the end of the show. On the podcasts and in the newsletter, he defends the booking.
Meltzer calls himself a journalist. I take that seriously, and that is the problem. He is also a lifelong wrestling fan, and for much of his career plenty of the people who ran wrestling treated him as a nuisance or an enemy. AEW treats him with respect. The man who owns the company calls him and talks about the show at length. I understand why he loves it. I would probably love it too.
But a fan with that much access has to ask how it does not warp his view over time. Part of a journalist’s job is to know when he is being flattered. Access is not a bribe. But the old warning about gifts was never only about crooks: “Thou shalt take no gift: for the gift blindeth the wise, and perverteth the words of the righteous” (Exodus 23:8). Deuteronomy repeats it almost word for word and sets it beside a ban on partiality: “Thou shalt not wrest judgment; thou shalt not respect persons, neither take a gift: for a gift doth blind the eyes of the wise” (Deuteronomy 16:19). The wise and the righteous. The gift works on honest men. Respect is a gift, and access works more quietly than money. You hear the booker’s reasons before you see the show, and after enough years the reasons start to sound like your own.
I am not saying he is paid or that Khan tells him what to write. He has covered stories that made AEW look bad, including the backstage fight after All Out in 2022 and its fallout. I cannot prove anything about what goes on in his head, and I may be wrong. My reading is that at times he sounds less like a reporter covering AEW than an advocate for it. Readers are entitled to weigh his defenses of the booking with the phone calls in mind. And when that same reporter tells critics they are haters, he is not refereeing the argument. He is in it.
What Some of Us Actually Think
Here is what this hater thinks.
AEW puts on a hell of a supershow. All In in London was really good. It was also long, and the wrestling was spot-heavy in the way the online audience loves. I enjoyed it. I can watch that style a few times a year. That is mostly how I watch AEW now: the pay-per-views, not Dynamite every week. The weekly show is overexposed for what it is.
AEW is largely a niche product for the online audience. The people who like it love it, and the pay-per-views prove that. None of this is hatred. It is a preference about dosage.
Then you get posts like this one, from a fan the day after Full Gear:
AEW is for the sickos who enjoy the best professional wrestling where the best wrestle and also a bloody and violent Deathmatch.
If you didn’t enjoy Full Gear last night to the point you call it “trash wrestling” then AEW isn’t for you and should just stop watching all together.
He was answering people who called it trash, and that is dismissive too. But look at his remedy. A lot of people do not like ultraviolence. That does not mean they hate AEW. The post bundles “the best wrestle” with the deathmatch and treats a dislike of one as a rejection of both. Then it shows the door to everyone who dislikes the deathmatch, not just the people who used the insult. A company whose fans do that is choosing to stay niche.
How I Got Here
The irony is that I came to this side of the argument from the other direction. I told the long version in How I Got Into Wrestling. The short version: I grew up on crash TV. I hated the old wrestling tropes and loved the booked-shoot chaos of the Attitude Era. I did not get the NWA or WCW for a long time. TNA was where I first understood the southern side of wrestling, and even then I identified with ECW’s counterculture over the old school.
Now I go back and enjoy the NWA material more. I love Smoky Mountain Wrestling. I am getting into Mid-South. The feud that pulled me into Mid-South, fittingly, has Jim Cornette in it. In 1984 he managed the Midnight Express, Bobby Eaton and Dennis Condrey, and they went after the tag team champions, Magnum T.A. and Mr. Wrestling II. They attacked Magnum and tarred and feathered him. They got the belts when Mr. Wrestling II turned on his own partner. Every beat set up the next one, and the turn paid off everything the Midnights had done to Magnum. Then the Rock ’n’ Roll Express were waiting.
What I found there was simplicity. Every segment had a purpose. Stories were serial and did not stop abruptly. Things had consequences. It was built for a local market, and it hooked people with emotion, not moves. I made the longer case for that engine in The Lost Art of Professional Wrestling. Today wrestlers mostly compete for star ratings and praise online. I do not think it works as well.
Who Was Over
This is the real disagreement, and it is older than X.
In the territories, nobody debated who was over. The promoter did not need a thread. Who was over was whoever the town would pay money to see, and the town told him every time that wrestler came back. If the building did not fill, the act was not over, however good the matches were.
Now “over” gets argued online, in replies and in star ratings, by people who will watch anyway. The town still votes, though. AEW has run Wembley Stadium three times. In 2023, Brent Council counted 72,265 people through the turnstiles. In 2024, 46,476 tickets were scanned. This year the council reported 41,102. Same building, same city, fewer people each time.
Forty-one thousand is a large crowd. Attendance falls for more than one reason: ticket prices, novelty wearing off, the date. I said All In was a good show, and I meant it. But a good show that fewer people come back to see is exactly what my reply to Meltzer described. It was over with one portion of the audience, and it pushed another away. That is not hate. That is the gate.
To be fair, AEW does not have to listen to anyone who left. It is privately owned and funded by the Khan family. Tony Khan does not have to fit my vision of wrestling or anyone else’s. A business usually wants to maximize profit, but it does not have to. If AEW is happy with the business it has, that is its call. But if it wants to grow, it has to listen to the people who left and understand that not all of it is hate.
Less Money, Fewer Believers
Cornette wrote this in 2009:
Twenty years ago, we PRETENDED to hurt each other, and the fans believed it. Today, we REALLY DO hurt each other, and the fans think it’s fake. Who are the marks now??
I would add one clause: and it draws less money. Not less pay for the top stars. Their contracts are bigger than any territory payoff. I mean less drawing power. Men used to pretend to beat each other up, and the town paid to see the heel get his. Now some of them legitimately hurt each other, take real risks, and fewer people come back. I wrote about where that escalation leads and who pays for it. That juxtaposition sits with me.
That is an argument. It might be wrong. It can be answered with numbers, with booking, with a good reason the turnstile count went down. “Haters” does not answer it.
I will probably buy the next All In. I will watch it to the end, even if it runs long. Wembley will count me.
Further Reading
- AEW All In 2026 records 41,102 turnstile count attendance, according to local government in London (POST Wrestling, Sept. 1, 2026; includes the 2023 and 2024 figures)
- Dave Meltzer on X: “52 week a year meltdown”
- Advice Dave Meltzer Messaged Tony Khan Live During AEW Revealed (WrestleTalk, July 17, 2023)
- Jim Cornette on Dave Meltzer’s Latest Twitter Comments About Cornette & Last (Jim Cornette Experience, YouTube)
- Dutch Mantell on why Dave Meltzer blocked him (Story Time with Dutch Mantell, Oct. 20, 2023)
- Jim Cornette, “The Slippery Slope of Hardcore Wrestling” (2009, reposted on Oklafan)
- The Midnight Express in Mid-South (Kayfabe Memories)
- How I Got Into Wrestling
- The Lost Art of Professional Wrestling
- Let the Heels Be Heels
- Nothing Fake About the Bill

